Hegseth’s controversial self-appointment to the archaic title of "Secretary of War" is more than a rhetorical flourish; it’s a deliberate statement of intent, signaling a radical departure from established Pentagon nomenclature and a challenge to the modern military’s self-perception. The title of "Secretary of War" was officially abolished in 1947 with the creation of the Department of Defense, a move designed to emphasize defense and inter-service cooperation rather than unilateral aggression. Hegseth’s reversion to the older title, accompanied by his public denouncements of the military as "weak" and "woke," reflects a broader ideological battle within the Trump administration, aiming to strip away what he perceives as progressive social policies and reassert a more traditionally aggressive, combat-focused identity. Critics argue this rebranding undermines civil-military relations and risks politicizing the armed forces, while supporters commend his bluntness and commitment to what they see as core martial values.

This week, however, the political maneuvering around Hegseth’s vision for the military will take a backseat to the looming threat of impeachment. US Representative Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican, on Monday (Nov 9) introduced eight articles of impeachment against Hegseth, triggering a two-day countdown to a potential House vote. The charges are grave, including waging war against Iran without congressional approval – a clear violation of constitutional war powers – and a range of other alleged abuses of power that strike at the heart of democratic governance. Should the House proceed, Hegseth would face a scrutiny not seen for a civilian defense leader in nearly 150 years.

The last, and to date only, civilian leader of the US military to be impeached by Congress was William Belknap, who held the title of Secretary of War in 1876. Belknap’s scandal-ridden tenure under President Ulysses S. Grant’s administration became a stark reminder of the accountability demanded of high office. Accused of taking substantial kickbacks from a post trader at Fort Sill, a lucrative position in Indian Territory, Belknap’s corruption was exposed amidst a period of widespread political graft following the Civil War. His impeachment proceedings began in the House just as a scheduled vote was set. In a desperate move to avoid the ignominy of impeachment, Belknap tendered his resignation to President Grant just hours before the House could vote. According to contemporary accounts and Senate history, he "burst into tears" upon realizing the depth of his predicament. Despite his resignation, the House proceeded to impeach him, asserting its constitutional authority to hold former officials accountable. The case then moved to the Senate for trial, where a fierce debate ensued over whether a private citizen, having resigned, could still be tried. The Senate ultimately decided it had jurisdiction, but later acquitted him, falling short of the required two-thirds majority by a narrow margin. Many senators, while acknowledging his guilt, voted for acquittal on the technicality that he was no longer in office, establishing a complex precedent for future impeachments of resigned officials. The Belknap case serves as a powerful historical mirror, highlighting the enduring tension between executive power, congressional oversight, and public trust.

Massie, a known libertarian and frequent critic of both military interventions and executive overreach, has positioned himself as a champion of congressional authority, particularly regarding the power to declare war. Speaking to reporters, he expressed concern that Republican leadership might attempt to bypass a direct vote on the impeachment articles through a procedural motion, such as a motion to table or to refer the resolution to a committee where it could languish. "They may try to get out of an actual vote on the substance of this. We should have a vote and a rigorous debate on these eight articles of impeachment," Massie asserted at a press conference, emphasizing the constitutional gravity of the situation. Such procedural maneuvers are common in congressional strategy, often employed to protect members from politically difficult votes or to sideline controversial legislation without a direct up-or-down decision.

Despite President Donald Trump’s Republicans still controlling the House until Democrats take over on Jan 3, congressional sources suggest the resolution may garner enough votes to pass. This internal division within the Republican ranks underscores a growing faction of conservatives, often aligned with libertarian principles, who are increasingly skeptical of military interventions and executive power, particularly after the perceived failures in Afghanistan and Iraq. However, the path to conviction in the Senate appears far more arduous, with a two-thirds majority required for removal from office. With Republicans holding 53 of 100 seats, securing the necessary 67 votes would require a significant defection of at least 20 Republican senators, a scenario widely considered improbable given the current political climate and the strong party loyalty often observed in impeachment proceedings.

US President Donald Trump, in an interview with Reuters on Monday, staunchly defended Hegseth, dismissing the impeachment effort as politically motivated and praising his Secretary’s performance. "Well, he won two wars. I don’t know how you can impeach him," Trump declared, pointing to the US military’s recent engagements in Iran and Venezuela as unmitigated successes. This narrative of "winning" wars, however, is a contentious one. The conflict in Iran, initiated without congressional authorization, has been characterized by military analysts as an ongoing, low-intensity proxy war, marked by strategic strikes and retaliatory actions, rather than a decisive victory. Similarly, the situation in Venezuela, where the US military reportedly deposed President Nicolás Maduro in a surprise January commando raid on his compound in the capital, Caracas, is far from a stable resolution. While Maduro’s ousting was a significant event, the long-term geopolitical stability and democratic transition in Venezuela remain deeply uncertain, with many experts questioning the legality and efficacy of such covert operations without explicit congressional oversight. Trump’s defense of Hegseth echoes his own repeated criticisms of prolonged foreign engagements, juxtaposing Hegseth’s swift actions with the "forever wars" of Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq, asking rhetorically: "Well, what about impeaching the people from Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq and all of that, where we fought forever and nothing happened?"

House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Republican, publicly opposed the impeachment effort, echoing concerns about national security and stability. He argued that impeachment "in the middle of hostilities abroad" would be "a terrible thing for our allies and our enemies to see," suggesting that such an internal political battle would project an image of weakness and disunity on the international stage. This sentiment reflects a traditional concern within political leadership to maintain a unified front during times of international tension, particularly when the nation’s top defense official is involved.

The impetus for the impeachment push is deeply intertwined with recent political shifts. Voter anger over the costly and controversial war in Iran played a significant role in helping Democrats win control of Congress in last week’s midterm elections. This public discontent has intensified divisions within the Republican Party, with figures like Vice President JD Vance publicly questioning the conflict’s strategy and objectives, a notable divergence from the administration’s official stance. Hegseth, by contrast, has vehemently defended the war as "courageous and historic," doubling down on the administration’s narrative despite dwindling public support and increasing congressional scrutiny. Recent polling data indicates that a majority of Americans, including a significant portion of independents, disapprove of the US involvement in Iran, fueling the political momentum behind accountability measures.

By contrast with Belknap, Hegseth is promising to stay and fight. He has launched a vigorous social media campaign, releasing a defiant video message last week stating he would not back down. He drew a parallel to Trump, who faced two impeachment proceedings, asserting: "It didn’t work against President Trump, and it won’t work with me." When asked about securing sufficient Republican support to defeat the impeachment push, Hegseth exuded confidence on Monday, declaring: "We’re not worried about that." He subsequently announced a Tuesday press conference, his first at the Pentagon since May, signaling his intent to directly address the accusations and present his defense to the public and the press. This combative stance underscores a broader strategy of direct engagement with political adversaries, a tactic popularized and perfected by President Trump.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who also serves as White House national security adviser, publicly defended Hegseth, calling the impeachment push "unfair." Telling reporters, "I think Pete’s done a good job. I really do," Rubio’s comments highlight the unified front among key members of the Trump administration, despite the internal party divisions. Rubio’s dual role as chief diplomat and national security advisor lends particular weight to his endorsement, suggesting a coordinated effort to insulate Hegseth from the political fallout.

DEFENSE SPENDING AT RISK?

Beyond the immediate political drama, some Republican lawmakers have expressed significant concern that if Hegseth remains in office, his already strained relationship with Congress will severely undermine the Trump administration’s efforts to secure a massive US$1.5 trillion defense spending package. This ambitious package is crucial for modernizing the military, funding ongoing operations, and addressing emerging threats. A breakdown in trust and cooperation between the Pentagon and Capitol Hill could lead to significant delays, reductions, or even outright rejection of critical appropriations, potentially jeopardizing national security and military readiness. Congressional oversight, particularly on defense spending, is a powerful lever, and a defense secretary perceived as antagonistic or unaccountable could face immense resistance in securing necessary funds.

Massie, a vocal Trump critic who is not seeking re-election and is set to leave office in January, issued a stark warning in a Monday statement. He cautioned that impeachment now would be "much gentler" than the intense scrutiny and potential legislative battles Hegseth would face once Democrats assume control of the House in January. "They will hold hearings and trials. President Trump should replace Secretary Hegseth now while he can still get a replacement confirmed in the Senate," Massie urged, highlighting the strategic advantage of preemptive action before the political landscape shifts. Democrats have, indeed, promised comprehensive investigations into Hegseth’s tenure, including controversial decisions such as the firing of the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and other senior military leaders, issues that could lead to protracted and damaging public hearings.

House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries affirmed his party’s resolve on Sunday, stating he was a "hard yes" on a measure to impeach Hegseth. Similarly, US Senator Chuck Schumer, a New York Democrat who is widely expected to become the Senate Majority Leader in the new year, declared on Monday that the Senate "needs to put Hegseth on trial." Schumer minced no words, stating, "Hegseth waged this war illegally, in open defiance of the Constitution and multiple War Powers Resolutions this Congress passed to end the fighting." This unified Democratic front signals a firm commitment to holding the administration accountable for its military actions and perceived constitutional overreach, setting the stage for an unprecedented confrontation.

Massie’s articles of impeachment accuse Hegseth of "high crimes and misdemeanors," a constitutional standard for impeachment that encompasses a range of offenses. The charges extend beyond the unauthorized war in Iran to various alleged abuses of power, including a particularly alarming accusation of violating the free speech rights of US Senator Mark Kelly, an Arizona Democrat. Last year, Hegseth reportedly sought to prosecute Kelly after the Senator and five other Democrats in Congress, all with backgrounds in the military and intelligence, urged US troops to refuse illegal orders. Hegseth accused them of sedition, a grave charge that President Trump amplified in a social media post at the time, stating it was "punishable by DEATH!" This incident raises profound questions about civil liberties, the separation of powers, and the appropriate limits of executive authority over elected officials. Legal scholars and constitutional experts have widely condemned Hegseth’s actions as a dangerous precedent, asserting that a cabinet secretary’s attempt to prosecute a sitting member of Congress for their speech constitutes a severe abuse of power and an attack on the legislative branch itself.

The looming impeachment of Pete Hegseth represents a confluence of historical precedent, constitutional questions, and deeply partisan politics. His controversial rebranding of the Defense Department, coupled with the unauthorized war in Iran and allegations of abusing executive power, has ignited a firestorm that threatens to destabilize the Pentagon and further polarize American governance. As the House prepares for a potential vote, the nation watches to see if Hegseth will indeed become the second civilian military leader in US history to face the ultimate congressional sanction, leaving an indelible mark on the legacy of the Trump administration and the future of civil-military relations.

By Jet Lee