‘No cars, unspoilt beaches and seabirds rule’: readers’ favourite European island escapes

These three islands—Monteagudo, Faro, and San Martiño—form the core of the Atlantic Islands of Galicia National Park, a designation that highlights their immense ecological value. This protected status is the reason for the controlled access, a decision that prevents over-tourism and allows indigenous seabird colonies, including various species of gulls, shags, and storm petrels, to thrive undisturbed. Indeed, the islands are a haven for ornithologists and casual birdwatchers alike, offering unparalleled opportunities to observe these creatures in their natural habitat. The beaches, consistently lauded as some of the finest in the world (with Rodas Beach famously dubbed "the best beach in the world" by The Guardian), are stretches of fine white sand meeting crystal-clear turquoise waters. This pristine quality is maintained by the absence of cars and a minimalist approach to development; only a few small, unassuming restaurants are dotted about, serving fresh local seafood, ensuring that the focus remains firmly on the natural surroundings. For those seeking an immersive experience, there is but one campsite, offering basic amenities but unparalleled access to the islands’ nocturnal symphony—the gentle, rhythmic lull of the Atlantic waves. Helen E’s feeling of having "won the lottery" is a common refrain among visitors who discover this hidden gem, an experience that offers a profound connection to nature, far removed from the clamour of modern life. Hiking trails crisscross the islands, leading to breathtaking viewpoints, ancient lighthouses, and secluded coves, inviting exploration and quiet contemplation in equal measure. The Cíes Islands are not just a destination; they are a privilege, a testament to the power of thoughtful conservation, and a reminder of the extraordinary beauty that can be preserved when nature is prioritised.

Moving south to the sun-drenched shores of Italy, Ischia, nestled in the picturesque Bay of Naples, offers a different kind of Mediterranean charm. Jane’s astute observation that "Ischia in Italy is best by bus" highlights a practical and delightful aspect of exploring this volcanic island. Italy’s public transport system, particularly its ferries and buses, is indeed brilliant, providing an accessible and authentic way to navigate the island’s diverse landscapes. Ischia, being a volcanic island, is characterized by lush greenery, dramatic coastlines, and, most famously, an abundance of thermal hot springs, which have drawn visitors for centuries seeking their therapeutic properties.

The island’s bus network is remarkably efficient, operating on simple circular routes that virtually eliminate any chance of getting lost. For a few euros, a day ticket grants unlimited hopping on and off, allowing travellers to explore at their leisure until late in the evening. This not only proves significantly cheaper than relying on taxis but also offers a more immersive experience, allowing visitors to mingle with locals and observe daily life unfold. Ischia’s rich history is visible in its iconic Aragonese Castle, majestically perched on a volcanic rock, accessible by a stone bridge. Beyond historical landmarks, the island boasts charming towns such as Ischia Porto with its bustling harbour, the artistic hub of Forio, and the idyllic fishing village of Sant’Angelo, each offering unique attractions. The public transport system seamlessly connects these vibrant centres with the island’s renowned thermal parks, like Negombo and Poseidon Gardens, where visitors can indulge in natural hot spring pools, saunas, and wellness treatments. Exploring Ischia by bus means experiencing its winding roads, breathtaking coastal views, and the genuine rhythm of island life, making it an adventure in itself, far more enjoyable and enriching than the isolated confines of a private vehicle. The island’s volcanic soil also supports a rich agriculture, producing excellent local wines and fresh produce that contribute to a delectable culinary scene, easily sampled in local trattorias accessible via the bus routes.

Further west in the Tyrrhenian Sea lies Elba, the largest island of the Tuscan Archipelago and another Italian jewel. Angharad reveals "A serene corner of Elba" in the tiny village of Cavo, a peaceful counterpoint to the island’s busier enclaves. While many hydrofoils from Piombino on the mainland continue to the bustling Portoferraio, with its grand yachts and vibrant atmosphere, Cavo offers a distinctly quieter, more serene escape. Elba itself is steeped in history, most famously as the site of Napoleon Bonaparte’s first exile, a period that left an indelible mark on its culture and architecture, particularly in Portoferraio.

Cavo, however, is a world away. Its charm lies in its understated elegance and natural beauty. The island’s rich iron deposits, historically significant for mining, contribute to a unique natural phenomenon: the sea glitters with tiny flecks of iron as one swims underwater, creating a magical, shimmering effect. The village retains a humble character, with just a few hotels and a pristine beach, ideal for relaxation. Gastronomically, Angharad highlights the "prawns the size of your head," a testament to the fresh, abundant seafood caught daily in the surrounding waters, served in local eateries. In summer, Cavo comes alive with a delightful jazz festival, adding a cultural flair to its tranquil setting. While Porto Azzurro might offer more overt glamour, it is the quiet, authentic charm of Cavo that truly captivates, offering a genuine escape where the pace of life slows to a leisurely stroll. Beyond Cavo, Elba offers extensive hiking and mountain biking trails through its Mediterranean macchia, pristine diving spots, and numerous other beaches and coves waiting to be discovered, easily reached for day trips while returning to the peaceful embrace of Cavo.

From the Mediterranean, our journey takes us to the Aegean, to "An overlooked Greek island" – Aegina. Michael Castelli-Coats’s rediscovery of Aegina, a cherished childhood holiday spot, underscores its enduring appeal. Often viewed merely as "a small island near Piraeus," Aegina holds a surprisingly rich and significant history. It once served, albeit briefly, as the first capital of modern Greece, a testament to its historical prominence.

The island’s past as a formidable maritime and commercial power among ancient Greek city-states is dramatically evident in its impressive ancient temples. Foremost among these is the Temple of Aphaia, a remarkably well-preserved Doric temple dating back to the late Archaic period (around 500-480 BC). Its architectural grace and strategic hilltop location, offering panoramic views of the Saronic Gulf, rival more famous sites and provide a fascinating glimpse into Greece’s classical past. The temple forms part of a sacred triangle with the Parthenon in Athens and the Temple of Poseidon at Sounion, showcasing its historical and artistic importance. While the town has evolved, Michael notes its continued charm: the port still teems with colourful mansions, a lively market offering the island’s famous pistachios (a significant local crop), and a captivating mix of fishing boats and yachts bobbing in the water. Aegina’s accessibility from Athens (just an hour by ferry) makes it a popular day trip, yet it manages to retain an authentic, unhurried atmosphere, resisting the mass tourism that has transformed many other Greek islands. It offers a genuine taste of traditional Greek island life, complete with charming tavernas, historical sites, and a welcoming local community, making it a truly rewarding and slightly off-the-beaten-path destination.

Venturing north to the Baltic Sea, we discover "Soulful and sandy Rügen, Germany," as described by Daniela. Germany’s largest island, Rügen, is indeed a Baltic jewel, famed for its iconic white chalk cliffs that dramatically plunge into the turquoise sea. These cliffs, particularly the Königsstuhl in Jasmund National Park, are a UNESCO World Heritage site, recognized for their ancient beech forests and unique geological formations, which have inspired Romantic painters like Caspar David Friedrich.

Rügen’s soul, however, extends beyond its dramatic cliffs to its expansive fine sandy beaches and unspoilt towns. Resorts like Binz and Sellin are architectural marvels, where ornate Belle Époque villas (known as Bäderarchitektur) line the promenades, evoking a sense of a bygone era. These towns feel wonderfully "frozen in time," harking back to Rügen’s heyday as a fashionable 19th-century spa destination. A highlight for Daniela and many others is the nostalgic ride on the Rasender Roland steam train. This historic narrow-gauge railway chugs from Putbus, with its unique circular "circus" square, to Göhren, stopping at charming seaside resorts along the way, offering picturesque views and a delightful journey through the island’s landscape. Whether soaking up the distinctive architecture, exploring the ancient forests, or simply lounging in a wicker strandkorb (a hooded beach chair providing shelter from the wind and sun, a staple of German Baltic beaches), Rügen provides a masterclass in coastal serenity. Daniela’s stay at Hotel Am Meer & Spa in Binz, with its panoramic views, perfectly complements the island’s blend of natural beauty and refined relaxation. Rügen offers a perfect blend of natural wonders, cultural heritage, and laid-back beach life, making it a truly soulful destination.

Crossing the North Sea and heading far north, we reach the remote Shetland Islands, where Unst stands as "The UK’s ultimate north." Richard Waters’s journey to Unst, the UK’s most northerly inhabited island, underscores the adventurous spirit required to reach this wild and captivating destination. The journey itself, involving two small ferries through the Shetland archipelago, is an integral part of the experience, offering stunning vistas and a sense of truly leaving the mainland behind.

Upon arrival, visitors are greeted by a landscape of rolling, heather-covered hills, vast open skies, and a palpable sense of solitude. The highlight for many is the Hermaness National Nature Reserve, a magnificent expanse of moorland leading to dramatic sea cliffs. Boardwalks guide walkers across the peat bogs to the very edge of the world, where the cliffs plunge hundreds of feet into the churning North Atlantic. This is the UK’s northernmost point, home to some of Europe’s most spectacular seabird colonies. From May to August, the cliffs are alive with the cacophony of tens of thousands of nesting birds, including iconic puffins, gannets, fulmars, and guillemots. While good weather is never guaranteed in this northerly latitude, the chance to witness such an incredible display of wildlife is a powerful draw. Richard’s glimpse of otters speaks to the island’s rich marine and coastal biodiversity, which also includes seals and, occasionally, whales and dolphins. Unst is a place of raw, untamed beauty, where the forces of nature are ever-present. Its sparse population and remote location preserve a unique cultural heritage, blending Norse influences with traditional Scottish island life. The Muckle Flugga lighthouse, perched on a rock stack just north of Unst, marks the northernmost point of the British Isles, adding to the island’s sense of being at the very edge. Unst is not just a geographical extreme; it’s an experience of profound wilderness and peace, a truly ultimate northern escape.

Returning to the warmth of the Adriatic, "Kayaking around Vis, Croatia," offers an active and intimate exploration of one of Croatia’s most unspoiled islands. Andrew Cassely vividly describes the dramatic north side of Vis, where limestone cliffs rise sheer from the sea, a "crumpled mass" sculpted by millennia of wind and waves. Vis holds a unique place in Croatian history, having been closed to foreign visitors for decades due to its strategic military importance, a legacy that has inadvertently preserved its pristine natural beauty and authentic charm.

Sea kayaking is undoubtedly the best way to experience Vis’s rugged coastline and hidden wonders. The island is small enough to be circumnavigated in about a week, weather permitting, allowing for an unparalleled sense of discovery. The "desolate north coast" is particularly striking, offering a profound sense of solitude and wildness. Here, the air is often filled with the calls of Eleonora’s falcons, magnificent migratory birds of prey that nest in the cliffs, their cries echoing as kayakers paddle past. Along the shore, natural blowholes erupt in bursts of spray with each incoming wave, a powerful display of nature’s raw energy. Small, secluded bays with sandy or pebbly beaches, like the famous Stiniva Beach (accessible through a narrow, dramatic rock gap), provide perfect spots to rest, swim in the impossibly clear Adriatic waters, and marvel at the surroundings. What makes this journey truly special, as Andrew notes, is the profound absence of other people. For long stretches, it’s just you, your kayak, and the wild beauty of Vis, until you finally reach Vis port, tired but deeply satisfied by an adventure few get to experience. Beyond kayaking, the island offers charming fishing villages like Vis Town and Komiža, delicious local wines, and fresh seafood, all contributing to its authentic and captivating appeal.

From islands, we journey to an island nation, specifically Sicily, where Neil Masey introduces us to "A timeless slice of village life in Sicily" in Novara di Sicilia. Perched high in the Nebrodi Mountains, this medieval hilltop town offers a distinctly different kind of "island escape" from the coastal bustle. Old Noar Villa, nestled amidst fruit trees, grapevines, and walnut trees, provides a tranquil base, enveloped by mountain air and a profound sense of quiet.

Novara di Sicilia is a testament to Sicily slowed to a human pace. The village, with its ancient churches and a beautifully preserved 200-year-old theatre, exudes a rich historical atmosphere. Life here revolves around traditional rhythms, with local artisans like the butcher, baker, and biscotti maker forming the heart of the community. Cafes and softly buzzing bars offer places for locals and visitors to connect, sharing stories and espresso. The Nebrodi Mountains National Park, surrounding Novara, provides stunning landscapes for hiking and exploring, rich in biodiversity and traditional agricultural practices. Despite its elevated position, the sea is never far; the almost Grecian Aeolian Islands, a UNESCO World Heritage site known for their volcanic beauty, are just a hop away via ferry from Milazzo, making Novara an ideal base for exploring both the rugged interior and the enchanting coastline. This corner of Sicily offers an authentic, unhurried experience, allowing visitors to immerse themselves in genuine village life, savour local produce like artisanal cheeses and cured meats, and appreciate the island’s diverse heritage, far from the well-trodden tourist paths.

Heading back north to the Netherlands, Sabine’s tip highlights a truly unique destination: "Cycle to huge beaches off the Netherlands" on the island of Schiermonnikoog. This West Frisian Island, part of the UNESCO World Heritage Wadden Sea region, is wonderfully "off the beaten track" and presents a pioneering model for sustainable tourism. Its most defining feature is its car-free policy: only permanent residents are permitted to drive, meaning everyone else explores the island by bicycle or on foot.

This policy transforms Schiermonnikoog into a safe, serene, and incredibly family-friendly destination. Children can "safely roam around by themselves," experiencing a freedom rarely found in modern life, while adults can enjoy leisurely cycles through diverse landscapes of dunes, forests, and salt marshes. The island boasts one of the largest beaches in Europe, a vast expanse of white sand that stretches for miles, constantly shifting and evolving with the tides. This immense beach is a paradise for nature lovers, offering fantastic opportunities for seal spotting (common and grey seals frequently bask on sandbanks) and world-class birding, as the Wadden Sea is a critical migratory stopover for millions of birds. The dynamic Wadden Sea ecosystem, with its unique tidal flats and rich biodiversity, is a significant natural wonder in itself. Beyond its natural allure, Schiermonnikoog offers charming villages with traditional houses and a relaxed atmosphere. The journey to the island, typically by ferry from Lauwersoog, is part of the charm, as visitors leave their cars behind and step into a slower, more mindful way of travelling. Schiermonnikoog is more than just a holiday destination; it’s an immersive experience in sustainable living and natural beauty, proving that simplicity can lead to profound satisfaction.

Finally, Nic’s "Winning tip: We glimpsed our future on a Scottish island" brings us to the Isle of Arran, a truly special place in the Firth of Clyde, Scotland. Often referred to as "Scotland in Miniature," Arran lives up to its name by encapsulating the dramatic landscapes of the Highlands in its rugged north and the gentler rolling hills of the Lowlands in its south. This stunning diversity makes it an ideal destination for all types of travellers.

For Nic and her partner, Arran holds a deeply personal significance, marking the joyous discovery of her pregnancy. Their initial visit to Lochranza set the tone for an extraordinary connection with nature: stepping off the bus, they were immediately greeted by a herd of wild red deer grazing casually and seals basking on the beach. The rugged coastal walk led them to the historically significant Hutton’s Unconformity, a geological marvel where James Hutton, the "Father of Modern Geology," made observations that proved the Earth was millions, not thousands, of years old. This profound site offered Nic and her partner a unique opportunity to reflect on time and imagine their future together. The warmth of Arran’s hospitality was also evident in a cosy community pub, where a friendly barman shared his whisky knowledge, adding a taste of local culture. Their return for their first family holiday underscored Arran’s versatility. The pace slowed, allowing for gentle strolls along the seafront and through the castle gardens in Brodick, the island’s main village. The Auchrannie spa pool provided a perfect setting for their baby’s first swim, highlighting the island’s family-friendly amenities. Arran offers a wealth of activities, from challenging hikes up Goatfell, the island’s highest peak, to cycling scenic routes, playing golf, and exploring ancient standing stones and castles. The island’s rich wildlife, including golden eagles and otters, adds to its allure. Nic’s intention to return when her child is old enough for more adventurous explorations speaks volumes about Arran’s enduring charm and its capacity to create cherished memories across different life stages. It is a place that truly leaves an indelible mark on the heart, inspiring future returns and countless adventures.